Skip to content
Start Your Quest
Uncategorized

Logic Model and Rationale for Evaluation Types: Public Health Diabetes Prevention Program

8 min read

Logic Model and Rationale for Evaluation Types: Diabetes Prevention Program (Public Health Program Evaluation)

In Week 1, you learned how a logic model connects a program’s resources, activities, outputs and intended outcomes. Now put that model into practice for a specific public health program evaluation. Choose a public health program to evaluate (from Week 1 or another program you are interested in); you will use it throughout the course, culminating in the Week 6 final project. As you move through each point of your logic model, consider which types of evaluation provide useful information and how formative and other approaches contribute to a comprehensive picture of the program’s progress, effectiveness and impact.

Preparation: Download the Logic Model Template; identify your program, assumptions, goals and objectives, stakeholders and contextual factors; review the Evaluation Types Table and the Parenting Logic Model Example.

Deliverable: Complete each column of the Logic Model Template. Write a 350- to 525-word rationale for the evaluation types in your logic model that:

  • Identifies the types of evaluation that could be conducted at each point in your logic model (formative evaluation).
  • Describes how each evaluation type applies to your program.
  • Describes how each evaluation type throughout the process is important to the overall status of the program (comprehensive evaluation).

Submit as a Microsoft Word document.

Matching evaluation types to each point in a logic model
Situation and inputs
Formative evaluation
Outputs
Process evaluation
Short and intermediate outcomes
Outcome evaluation
Long-term outcomes
Impact evaluation
Across the model
Economic and culturally responsive
Comprehensive view
Each link tested

Download the logic model and rationale (.docx)

Completed Logic Model: Riverside County Diabetes Prevention Program (Fictional Setting)

Logic model elementProgram content
SituationIn Riverside County (fictional), an estimated 1 in 3 adults has prediabetes, most are unaware of it, and type 2 diabetes rates are highest among low-income, Black and Hispanic residents with limited access to preventive programs.
PrioritiesPrevent or delay type 2 diabetes among adults with prediabetes; reduce disparities by reaching low-income, Black and Hispanic residents; partner with primary care for referrals.
Inputs (what we invest)CDC-recognized lifestyle change curriculum; 4 trained Lifestyle Coaches (2 bilingual); health department funding and grant; community center and church meeting space; partner clinics for referrals; digital scales and tracking app; data system for CDC reporting; evaluation staff.
Outputs: who we reachAdults 18+ with prediabetes or high risk (BMI ≥25, or ≥23 for Asian Americans), prioritizing low-income, Black and Hispanic residents; referring clinicians; family members.
Outputs: what we doScreen and refer through partner clinics; deliver the year-long program (weekly sessions for the first 6 months, then at least monthly), in English and Spanish, in person and virtually; weekly weigh-ins and activity logs; coach follow-up calls.
Outputs: what we createCohorts of 15–20 participants; session attendance and weight records; bilingual materials; referral pathway with clinics; reports to CDC every 6 months.
Short-term outcomes (learning)Participants increase knowledge of prediabetes, healthy eating, physical activity and coping; increase confidence in self-monitoring.
Intermediate outcomes (action)Participants reach 150 minutes of activity per week, track food and activity, and lose 5–7% of body weight by month 12.
Long-term outcomes (conditions)Reduced incidence of type 2 diabetes among participants; lower A1C; reduced county diabetes disparities and health care costs.
AssumptionsClinicians will screen and refer; participants can attend and are motivated; lifestyle change reduces diabetes risk as shown in the Diabetes Prevention Program trial; bilingual delivery improves reach.
External factorsFood environment and cost of healthy food; transportation; work schedules; insurance coverage of the program; competing community programs; public health funding changes.
SMART goals(1) Enroll 120 eligible adults, at least 60% Black or Hispanic, by June 30, 2027. (2) At least 60% of participants attend 9+ sessions in months 1–6. (3) At least 50% of completers achieve 5% weight loss by month 12. (4) At least 60% report 150 minutes of weekly activity by month 6.
EvaluationFormative: needs assessment and pilot testing. Process: reach, attendance, fidelity, participant satisfaction. Outcome: knowledge, activity and weight change. Impact: diabetes incidence and A1C over 3–5 years. Economic: cost per participant and per kilogram lost. Culturally responsive lens throughout.

The county, coaches and targets are fictional. The program model follows CDC’s National Diabetes Prevention Program lifestyle change program. In the Word file, the logic model is laid out in the template’s columns.

Model rationale (350–525 words)

Original example for study purposes (about 440 words). Fictional county and targets; replace with your own program, and reference your course’s Evaluation Types Table.

Rationale for Evaluation Types

The Riverside County Diabetes Prevention Program applies the CDC-recognized lifestyle change program, which helped participants in the original Diabetes Prevention Program reduce their risk of type 2 diabetes by 58% (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], n.d.-a). Different evaluation types fit different points in the logic model.

Situation, priorities and inputs: formative evaluation. Before launch, a needs assessment using county prediabetes and diabetes data, focus groups with Black and Hispanic residents and interviews with clinic partners would confirm the problem and test whether bilingual sessions, meeting locations and schedules fit the community. Pilot testing materials with a small group allows revisions before full rollout. Formative evaluation is important because it ensures the program is designed for the people it intends to reach.

Outputs: process (implementation) evaluation. Process evaluation examines whether activities are delivered as planned, including reach, dose, fidelity and barriers (CDC, n.d.-b). For this program, it would track referrals, enrollment by race, ethnicity and income, session attendance, coach adherence to the curriculum and participant satisfaction. If attendance drops after month three, the team can add evening or virtual sessions. Process data are essential because outcomes cannot be interpreted if the program was not delivered as designed.

Short-term and intermediate outcomes: outcome evaluation. Outcome evaluation determines whether the program achieves its intended results (CDC, n.d.-b). Pre- and post-tests would measure knowledge and confidence, activity logs would measure progress toward 150 minutes per week, and weigh-ins would measure progress toward 5–7% weight loss, the program’s research-based goal (CDC, n.d.-a). These results show whether participants are learning and changing behavior, the mechanisms expected to lower diabetes risk.

Long-term outcomes: impact evaluation. Impact evaluation would compare diabetes incidence and A1C among participants with a matched group of eligible nonparticipants over three to five years, and monitor county disparities. This shows whether the program changes conditions, not just individual behavior.

Across the model: economic and culturally responsive evaluation. Economic evaluation compares costs and consequences (CDC, n.d.-b), such as cost per participant and per diabetes case prevented, which supports funding decisions. A culturally responsive lens examines whether the program works equally well for Black, Hispanic and low-income participants and includes their perspectives in interpreting results.

Comprehensive evaluation. Together, these evaluation types create a complete picture. Formative evaluation builds the right program, process evaluation confirms it is delivered well, outcome evaluation shows whether participants change, and impact and economic evaluation show whether the change matters for the community and justifies investment. Evaluating each link also tests the logic model’s assumptions; if outcomes fall short, process data reveal whether the cause is implementation or the theory of change, guiding improvement throughout the program.

References

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (n.d.-a). What is the National DPP? https://www.cdc.gov/diabetes-prevention/programs/what-is-the-national-dpp.html

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (n.d.-b). Types of evaluation. VetoViolence. https://vetoviolence.cdc.gov/apps/evaluaction/assets/pdf/Types-of-Evaluation.pdf

Knowler, W. C., Barrett-Connor, E., Fowler, S. E., Hamman, R. F., Lachin, J. M., Walker, E. A., & Nathan, D. M. (2002). Reduction in the incidence of type 2 diabetes with lifestyle intervention or metformin. New England Journal of Medicine, 346(6), 393–403. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa012512

University of Wisconsin–Extension. (2003). Program development and evaluation: Logic model. University of Wisconsin–Extension.

Related: CJUS 801 evaluation strategy and logic model.

Tip: Label the evaluation type beside each logic model column in your Word file so your instructor can see the match between the model and your rationale at a glance.

Frequently asked questions

Which program should I choose?

One you can use through Week 6, with enough information to fill every column, such as a diabetes prevention, smoking cessation, vaccination or maternal health program.

Is formative evaluation only done before launch?

Mostly, but it can continue whenever materials or activities are adapted.

What is the difference between outcome and impact evaluation?

Outcome evaluation measures changes in participants’ knowledge and behavior; impact evaluation measures longer-term changes in health conditions, often compared with a comparison group.

More model assignments posted today

  • Satterfield and Manduley legislator votes
  • Five-Minute University criminology reflection
  • EDET 8005 teacher leadership paper
  • Capella practicum Assessment 4
  • Capella practicum Assessment 3
  • ECO 550 dynamic pricing case study
  • Discharge planning process improvement slides
  • Youth mental health digital newspaper
  • AI mental health chatbots article

Academic Writer & Editor
WhatsApp