EDET 8005 Teacher Leadership Scholarly Inquiry: Foundations, Georgia Standards and Certification, and the Future of Teacher Leadership
EDET 8005 Teacher Leadership Scholarly Inquiry: Foundations, Georgia’s Standards and Certification, and the Future of Teacher Leadership
EDET 8005: Teacher Leadership. Scholarly Inquiry and Critical Analysis Assignment. Produce a comprehensive, evidence-based examination of teacher leadership, supported by credible scholarly literature, current research and state and national policy, written in an authentic academic voice with APA 7 citations. The assignment has three parts:
- Part I: Foundations and Evolution of Teacher Leadership. Review and synthesize literature on the historical evolution, contemporary models and national or international perspectives of teacher leadership; its relationship to instructional improvement and school effectiveness; and its influence on educators’ roles.
- Part II: Teacher Leadership in Georgia. Examine Georgia’s seven Teacher Leadership Standards; certification requirements including applicable GACE assessments; advanced degree pathways at Georgia public universities and degree levels; district salary advancement for teachers earning Teacher Leadership degrees or endorsements while remaining in the classroom; and whether all districts recognize these qualifications on higher salary schedules.
- Part III: Critical Perspectives and the Future of Teacher Leadership. Synthesize findings; evaluate strengths, opportunities and policy implications; explore links to recruitment, retention, satisfaction and career advancement; and distinguish documented findings from personal interpretation.
Waves, models, evidence
Seven program standards (505-3-.72)
Service field, mentor, assessment
M.Ed., Ed.S., Ed.D.
Certificate level and upgrade rule
Strengths, gaps, workforce
Download the APA paper (.docx)
Model response
Original example for study purposes (about 2,220 words). Verify current GaPSC assessment requirements and add two or three district salary schedules where marked.
Introduction
Most teachers who want to lead face an awkward choice. The traditional ladder runs out of the classroom: assistant principal, principal, district office. Teacher leadership offers a different idea, that a teacher can shape instruction across a school while still teaching students every day. Georgia has gone further than many states in turning that idea into formal structures, with program standards, a certificate field and degree pathways. This paper reviews how teacher leadership developed as a concept, examines Georgia’s framework in detail and offers a critical view of where the field is heading, separating what the evidence shows from my own professional interpretation.
Part I: Foundations and Evolution of Teacher Leadership
From Formal Roles to Collective Practice
Scholars often describe teacher leadership as developing in waves. Early forms placed teachers in formal, managerial positions such as department head or union representative, roles that kept schools running but rarely touched instruction. A second wave drew on teachers’ instructional expertise through positions such as curriculum developer or staff developer. A third wave reframed leadership as part of the culture of a school, something teachers exercise through collaboration rather than through a title (York-Barr & Duke, 2004). That shift matters. It moves teacher leadership from a reward for a few veterans to an expectation that many teachers can share responsibility for improvement.
York-Barr and Duke’s (2004) review remains a landmark because it defined the field and also exposed its weaknesses. They described teacher leadership as the process by which teachers influence colleagues, principals and the school community to improve teaching and learning. They also noted that much of the research was descriptive, relied on small samples and rarely measured student outcomes. A decade later, Wenner and Campbell (2017) reviewed the literature again and reached a similar conclusion: definitions were still inconsistent, many studies did not define teacher leadership at all and the link to student achievement remained thinly documented. Their review did find consistent evidence that teacher leaders influence colleagues’ practice and school culture, and that principal support, time and clear roles determine whether teacher leadership succeeds.
Contemporary Models
Several models now guide practice. Katzenmeyer and Moller (2009) described teacher leaders as those who lead within and beyond the classroom, identify with a community of learners and influence others toward improved practice. Their metaphor of teachers as a “sleeping giant” captured the idea that schools underuse their most direct source of instructional expertise. Distributed leadership models extend this by viewing leadership as spread across formal and informal roles rather than concentrated in the principal. Professional learning communities, instructional coaching and peer observation all depend on teachers who can facilitate colleagues’ learning.
In 2011, the Teacher Leadership Exploratory Consortium published the Teacher Leader Model Standards, which organized the work into seven domains: fostering a collaborative culture; accessing and using research; promoting professional learning; facilitating improvements in instruction; promoting the use of assessment and data; improving outreach and collaboration with families and community; and advocating for student learning and the profession (Teacher Leadership Exploratory Consortium, 2011). These domains gave states and universities a common vocabulary, and, as Part II shows, Georgia’s program standards closely follow them.
Relationship to Instruction and School Effectiveness
The theory of action behind teacher leadership is straightforward: teacher leaders improve colleagues’ instruction, and better instruction improves student learning. The evidence is strongest for the first link. Studies consistently show that teacher leaders shape collaboration, professional learning and instructional practice (Wenner & Campbell, 2017). The second link, from teacher leadership to student achievement, is harder to demonstrate because the effects are indirect and mixed with many other influences. Smylie and Eckert (2018) argued that the field has relied too much on “superhero” teacher leaders and too little on building the organizational conditions, such as time, structures and principal support, that allow leadership capacity to grow across a whole staff.
Influence on Professional Roles
Teacher leadership has blurred the line between teaching and administration. Hybrid roles, in which teachers split time between their own classrooms and coaching or curriculum work, have expanded. These roles can give experienced teachers a path to growth without leaving students. They also create tension. Teacher leaders often report role ambiguity, strained relationships with peers who see them as quasi-administrators and too little time to do both jobs well (Wenner & Campbell, 2017). The literature, in short, presents teacher leadership as promising but fragile: its benefits depend heavily on how schools design and support the role.
Part II: Teacher Leadership in Georgia
Georgia’s Seven Teacher Leadership Standards
The Georgia Professional Standards Commission (GaPSC) sets requirements for Teacher Leadership preparation programs in Rule 505-3-.72. The rule identifies seven program standards that approved programs must prepare candidates to meet. Summarized by focus, teacher leaders: (1) design and implement sustained, job-embedded professional learning based on student and teacher needs; (2) build a collaborative school culture focused on excellence and continuous improvement; (3) understand curriculum and align curriculum, instruction and assessment to standards; (4) model effective pedagogy and serve as mentors and coaches; (5) design assessment practices and use data for decision-making; (6) access and apply research to improve teaching and learning; and (7) advocate for the differentiated needs of students, colleagues, families and stakeholders (Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 505-3-.72, 2024).
These standards have clear implications for practice. They define teacher leadership as instructional and collaborative rather than managerial. A teacher leader in Georgia is expected to lead professional learning, coach peers and use data, not to supervise or evaluate colleagues. The close parallel to the national Teacher Leader Model Standards also means Georgia candidates are prepared within a nationally recognized framework.
Program and Certification Requirements
Georgia treats Teacher Leadership as a service field certificate for grades P-12. Educators holding a valid Clear Renewable or Level 4+ Georgia teaching, service or leadership certificate can add the field by completing a GaPSC-approved program and passing the state-approved content assessment (Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 505-2-.209). Program admission requires a level 4 or higher certificate, a recommendation from a school system administrator, at least one year of successful classroom teaching and a partnership agreement between the program provider and the employing school system. Completion requires intensive support from an experienced mentor, an Individualized Growth Plan developed with that mentor and work samples demonstrating the standards (Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 505-3-.72, 2024). The partnership requirement is distinctive: Georgia frames teacher leadership preparation as a joint effort between universities and districts, grounded in real school work.
The state-approved content assessment for this field has been the GACE Teacher Leadership Assessment, a performance-based assessment in which candidates submit evidence of leadership work rather than taking a conventional multiple-choice test. Because the GACE Teacher Leadership web pages now redirect to the GaPSC testing page, candidates should confirm the current assessment requirement and format directly with GaPSC before planning their pathway.
Advanced Degree Pathways
Several University System of Georgia institutions offer Teacher Leadership degrees at multiple levels. Kennesaw State University offers a Master of Education in Teacher Leadership (including a combined Teacher Leadership and Educational Leadership Tier I option), an Education Specialist in Teacher Leadership and a Doctor of Education in Teacher Leadership (Kennesaw State University, n.d.-a, n.d.-b, n.d.-c). Valdosta State University and Georgia College & State University offer Education Specialist programs in Teacher Leadership (Georgia College & State University, n.d.; Valdosta State University, n.d.). Teacher Leadership pathways therefore exist at the master’s (level 5), specialist (level 6) and doctoral (level 7) levels, consistent with the program levels described in Rule 505-3-.72. [Add any additional Georgia programs your course identifies, and verify current offerings on each university’s website.]
Salary Advancement for Classroom Teachers
Georgia pays teachers on a state salary schedule organized by certificate level and years of experience, with columns such as T-4 (bachelor’s), T-5 (master’s), T-6 (specialist) and T-7 (doctorate). Districts add local supplements on top of the state base, which is why published schedules from districts such as Cobb County and Atlanta Public Schools differ even though they share the same certificate-level structure. A teacher therefore earns more on the salary schedule only when the higher degree produces a higher certificate level.
That is where Georgia’s certificate upgrade rule becomes decisive. Since the rule was revised effective July 1, 2014, an advanced degree earns an upgrade only if it is in a field the educator holds or if it is a state-approved program that adds a new certificate field (Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 505-2-.33). Teacher Leadership appears in the rule’s legacy provisions, which allowed educators enrolled in such programs by January 15, 2013 to upgrade under earlier requirements if they finished by set deadlines. For teachers today, the practical implication is that a Teacher Leadership degree supports an upgrade when it is a GaPSC-approved program through which the teacher adds the Teacher Leadership certificate field. A degree that does not lead to the certificate may not raise the teacher’s level.
Do All Districts Recognize These Qualifications?
Because the state salary schedule is tied to certificate level, a district that follows the state schedule places a teacher on a higher column once GaPSC issues the upgraded certificate. In that sense, recognition does not depend on district preference. Differences among districts appear in three places: the size of local supplements for each level, whether a district offers additional stipends for teacher leader roles such as instructional coach or department chair and whether the district has a formal partnership with a Teacher Leadership program, which Rule 505-3-.72 requires for admission. [Verify with two or three district salary schedules, for example your own district and a neighboring one, and cite them.] My review suggests the more accurate answer to the prompt is that districts recognize the upgraded certificate level, but they do not uniformly reward teacher leadership roles beyond that.
Part III: Critical Perspectives and the Future of Teacher Leadership
Strengths of Existing Frameworks
Georgia’s framework has real strengths. First, its standards are instructional. By emphasizing professional learning, coaching, data and research, they keep teacher leaders close to teaching and learning, which is where the research finds their influence is strongest (Wenner & Campbell, 2017). Second, the district partnership and mentor requirements anchor preparation in actual school work, addressing a long-standing criticism that leadership preparation is too theoretical. Third, the availability of degrees at three levels gives teachers a long-term pathway, from a master’s degree to a doctorate, without leaving the classroom.
Opportunities for Improvement
The weaknesses are just as important. Documented research shows that teacher leaders struggle with role ambiguity and lack of time (Wenner & Campbell, 2017; York-Barr & Duke, 2004). Certification alone does not solve these problems. A teacher can earn a Teacher Leadership certificate and return to a school with no structured leadership role, no release time and no stipend. In that case, the state has invested in expertise that the system does not use. The salary structure also rewards the credential, not the leadership work. A teacher who coaches colleagues every week without an upgrade earns no more than a peer who does not.
In my professional interpretation, the next step for Georgia would be to connect the credential to defined roles: hybrid positions with protected time, clear job descriptions and modest stipends tied to leadership responsibilities. Smylie and Eckert’s (2018) argument about building capacity across a school supports this view. The goal should be to create structures in which many teachers can lead, rather than to certify individual heroes.
Teacher Leadership and the Workforce Pipeline
The workforce question gives teacher leadership new urgency. National research has long documented that teacher attrition drives shortages and that many teachers who leave cite working conditions, lack of support and limited career advancement (Sutcher et al., 2016). Teacher leadership addresses several of these factors at once. It offers career growth without leaving the classroom, builds collaborative cultures that make schools better places to work and provides mentoring for new teachers, who are most likely to leave.
The evidence, however, is more suggestive than conclusive. Few studies directly measure whether teacher leadership roles reduce attrition, and teachers in poorly designed hybrid roles may experience more stress, not less. My interpretation is that teacher leadership can support retention when the role adds meaning and influence without simply adding hours. Georgia’s framework provides the preparation; districts control whether the role is sustainable.
Policy Implications
Three implications follow. States that lack formal pathways could adapt Georgia’s model, especially its mentor and partnership requirements. Georgia could strengthen its model by encouraging districts to create career ladders that pay for leadership roles as well as degrees. Finally, researchers and districts should collect better data on what teacher leaders do and how their work affects colleagues, students and retention, so that future policy rests on stronger evidence.
Conclusion
Teacher leadership has evolved from managerial roles to a shared, instructional practice, and the research consistently links it to stronger collaboration and professional learning, even though its effect on student achievement remains hard to isolate. Georgia stands out for building a coherent system of standards, certification and degree pathways, and its salary schedule rewards teachers whose degrees produce certificate upgrades. The remaining gap lies between credential and role. If Georgia and its districts can turn certified teacher leaders into supported, recognized leaders in their schools, teacher leadership could become a meaningful answer to the profession’s retention and career advancement challenges.
References
Georgia College & State University. (n.d.). Education Specialist in Teacher Leadership. https://www.gcsu.edu/index.php/education/proflearning/teacher-leadership-eds
Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 505-2-.33 (2021). Certificate upgrade. https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/georgia/Ga-Comp-R-Regs-R-505-2-.33
Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 505-2-.209. Teacher leadership. https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/georgia/Ga-Comp-R-Regs-R-505-2-.209
Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 505-3-.72 (2024). Teacher leadership program. https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/georgia/Ga-Comp-R-Regs-R-505-3-.72
Katzenmeyer, M., & Moller, G. (2009). Awakening the sleeping giant: Helping teachers develop as leaders (3rd ed.). Corwin.
Kennesaw State University. (n.d.-a). Doctor of Education in Teacher Leadership. https://www.kennesaw.edu/degrees-programs/doctoral-degrees/teacher-leadership.php
Kennesaw State University. (n.d.-b). Ed.S. Teacher Leadership. https://bagwell.kennesaw.edu/degrees-programs/specialist/teacher-leadership.php
Kennesaw State University. (n.d.-c). Master of Education in Teacher Leadership and Educational Leadership. https://www.kennesaw.edu/degrees-programs/master-degrees/teacher-leadership.php
Smylie, M. A., & Eckert, J. (2018). Beyond superheroes and advocacy: The pathway of teacher leadership development. Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 46(4), 556–577. https://doi.org/10.1177/1741143217694893
Sutcher, L., Darling-Hammond, L., & Carver-Thomas, D. (2016). A coming crisis in teaching? Teacher supply, demand, and shortages in the U.S. Learning Policy Institute.
Teacher Leadership Exploratory Consortium. (2011). Teacher leader model standards.
Valdosta State University. (n.d.). Ed.S. Teacher Leadership. https://valdosta.edu/colleges/education/teacher-education/programs/misc-eds-teacher-leadership
Wenner, J. A., & Campbell, T. (2017). The theoretical and empirical basis of teacher leadership: A review of the literature. Review of Educational Research, 87(1), 134–171. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654316653478
York-Barr, J., & Duke, K. (2004). What do we know about teacher leadership? Findings from two decades of scholarship. Review of Educational Research, 74(3), 255–316. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543074003255
Tip: Keep a clear line between documented findings (cite them) and your own interpretation (signal it with phrases such as “In my professional view”); Part III is graded on that distinction.
Frequently asked questions
Does a Teacher Leadership degree always raise a Georgia teacher’s salary?
Only when it produces a certificate upgrade under GaPSC rules, typically by completing an approved program and adding the Teacher Leadership field.
Is the GACE Teacher Leadership assessment still required?
Rule 505-2-.209 requires a state-approved content assessment; confirm the current test with GaPSC, as the GACE Teacher Leadership pages now redirect to GaPSC.
Which theory should anchor Part I?
York-Barr and Duke (2004) and Wenner and Campbell (2017) are the core reviews; add distributed leadership or the Teacher Leader Model Standards.
More model assignments posted today
- Satterfield and Manduley legislator votes
- Five-Minute University criminology reflection
- Capella practicum Assessment 4
- Capella practicum Assessment 3
- ECO 550 dynamic pricing case study
- Discharge planning process improvement slides
- Youth mental health digital newspaper
- AI mental health chatbots article
- Logic model and evaluation types rationale